This is a post from Alex Carrick's blog that covers the Canadian construction industry.

Since 1985, Mr. Carrick has held the position of Canadian Chief Economist with Reed Construction Data's CanaData, the leading supplier of statistics and forecasting information for the Canadian construction industry.

Go to Alex Carrick's blog home

Construction Industry Forecasts

Notes from Alex Carrick - May 07, 2009

Alex Carrick
CanaData’s Construction Starts are Depressed, But a Familiar Pattern is Emerging

CanaData’s construction starts statistics through April 2009 remain quite depressed. Total square footage in all categories of construction − residential, ICI and engineering − is -52% year to date versus the first four months of last year. The dollar volume of starts is -30%. That being said, however, an interesting pattern has emerged within the type-of-structure categories and it shows up most readily in the Top 10 starts list for the month.

Nine of the top 10 construction project starts in April were either engineering or institutional work. Six were the former and three were the latter. Only one project came from another category and that was a 32-storey residential tower in British Columbia. The Top 10 and trend graph have been posted and can be accessed by clicking here.

Privately-funded Work Dries Up; Public Sector Steps Forward

This is a remarkable configuration. It clearly demonstrates what is happening in the marketplace. Privately-funded work in such areas as office buildings, retail stores, warehouses and manufacturing plants has dried up. The recession, job losses and lack of credit have stopped construction plans. But the public sector is stepping up to the plate. As promised in nearly every budget, infrastructure spending is being pushing forward.

Engineering work, so far, has been mainly sewage and water treatment plants. These kinds of projects are proceeding in Saint John NB, Brampton and Leamington ON, Neepawa MB and Saskatoon SK. Municipalities are proceeding with this work with or without firm cost-sharing commitments from the other two levels of government. Some of the work is proceeding on speculation that the money will be forthcoming later.

Two of the large institutional projects are in British Columbia and are hospital additions, in Kelowna and Vernon. The other major institutional job is the start on the Canadian Museum for Human Rights in Winnipeg, Manitoba. This project’s launch is the fulfillment of a dream by the Asper family, one of the giants in Canadian publishing.

Percentage Change by Type of Structure

Due to the foregoing mix of work, institutional construction is the only category to show a year-over-year increase in starts (+1% in square footage and +56% in dollar volume). Industrial starts have been weakest so far this year (-71% in square footage and -78% in dollars), with commercial also down substantially (-67% in square footage and -51% in dollars). By comparison, engineering starts have performed okay (-16% in dollars).

This is a pattern that is likely to continue as the rest of the year unfolds and as government infrastructure spending gains more traction. Regionally, the only province that is standing apart, with a better record than the rest, is Manitoba (-14% in square footage and +58% in dollars). Almost all of the others have dropped by half or more. The three western-most provinces are down by around 60%. The fall in commodity prices since last July has caused investment spending to be slashed in those resource-dependent regions. Ontario and Québec starts are also weak, but not to quite the same degree.

Alex Carrick


RSS Feed

» back to blog home

Member Comments

Posted by Alex Carrick
The -4.7% figure is a "put-in-place" figure. Investment or put-in-place numbers are much smoother than starts numbers. CanaData records the total value or square footage of a start at the time ground is broken. Put-in-place numbers are like progress payments. They are recorded as the project goes up. Therefore, swings in the first series are much wider than swings in the second. The easiest way to think of this is in terms of a $60 million office building. It goes into the starts as a "lumpy" $60 million at once. But it goes into investment dollars (in a hypothetical example) as $20 million in the first year, $30 million in the second and $10 in the final year. Peaks in cycles have a large number of "lumpy" starts. Then there is carry-over investment work for some years after that. The investment number comes from Statistics Canada's survey of owners. It is reported in the publication Private and Public Investment in Canada. I would say that it is too optimistic. A decline in spending of 10% to 15% seems more likely. The -50% figure for ICI (industrial, commercial and institutional) starts would seem to be a relatively realistic measure of what is currently happening in the marketplace. Privately-financed work is drying up. There may be some moderation in this decline (say to -40% by the end of the year), due to public projects in the institutional category. Alex Carric
Posted by David Henderson
Alex, on Apr 22 you said new construction would fall by 4.7% in 2009. Your may 7 article talks about a 52% drop in ICI. How do you reconcile the two numbers and where do you think it is going to end up by the end of the year?
Post Your Own Comments 
» Not a member? Register now to become one. Otherwise, login to post your comments on this article.

Read Other Recent Alex Carrick Posts

10/12 - Latest Economic Nuggets: Mid-October 2012
10/04 - Auto Sales Set a Blistering Pace in the U.S. and Canada
09/18 - Canada’s Energy Future is Assured, Right? Think Again
09/14 - Latest Economic Nuggets: Mid-September 2012
09/06 - Auto Sector Labor Relations will Play a Role in Construction Outlook
08/30 - Raucous Behavior in the Party Room Next Door
08/13 - Latest Economic Nuggets: Mid-August 2012
07/31 - Canada’s GDP Advanced a Timid 0.1% in May but Support Will Come from Better U.S. Home Prices
07/19 - Finding the Pearls in the Latest U.S. and Canadian Economic News
07/13 - Latest Economic Nuggets: Mid-July 2012
07/04 - U.S. Auto Sales Continue Bullish While Canadian Incomes Languish
06/28 - Three Pivot Points for the World Economy - U.S. Housing, Europe’s Conundrum and Oil Prices
06/14 - Economic Nuggets – June 15, 2012
06/06 - Canada’s First Quarter GDP Growth Met Expectations, But What Comes Next?
05/30 - Ontario has a Backbone of Strength for the Decade Ahead
05/14 - Economic Nuggets - May 15, 2012
05/11 - Canada Rode a Second Consecutive Month of Strong Job Gains in April
05/04 - U.S. Employment Rose by a Mediocre 115,000 in April
04/27 - U.S. GDP +2.2% in Q1 2012 and Alberta led Canadian Provinces in 2011
04/18 - U.S. Inflation Low in March; Canada’s Central Bank Looking to Raise Rates

click here to update your log-in and member information

click here to maintain your company profile & view metrics