This is a post from Alex Carrick's blog that covers the Canadian construction industry.

Since 1985, Mr. Carrick has held the position of Canadian Chief Economist with Reed Construction Data's CanaData, the leading supplier of statistics and forecasting information for the Canadian construction industry.

Go to Alex Carrick's blog home

Construction Industry Forecasts

Notes from Alex Carrick - Feb 08, 2012

Alex Carrick
Home starts and job levels diverge in Canada and the U.S.

Many factors determine the level of home starts in a region and in any given time period including prices and mortgage rates, which are usually wrapped up in the term affordability.

Another key determinant, one would think would be the availability of jobs.

As jobs and incomes increase, the demand for housing should grow. There should be a close tie-in.

What’s currently being witnessed in both Canada and the U.S. is an inversion of the equation. Furthermore, the abnormal pattern is the opposite between the two countries.

In Canada, homebuilding remains strong at a time when jobs growth has leveled off.

In the United States, ground-breakings are flat while employment is showing definite signs of improvement.

Let’s begin with Canada.

Home starts in January were 197,900 units, seasonally adjusted and annualized, according to Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation (CMHC).

A figure near 200,000 units or above is a strong level of starts in Canada. That mark has been reached in six of the past eight months. There is increasing concern that Canada’s housing market may be too hot.

Some of the worry is focused on prices. Homes on the Pacific coast, in particular, are judged to be too expensive. Some correction is already taking place.

Existing home prices in Vancouver (-1.7%) and Victoria (-5.5%) dropped year over year in January, according to the Canadian Real Estate Association (CREA).

The average price of resale homes in Victoria has fallen back near Toronto’s level, but Vancouver remains about 70% higher.

Another problem may be household debt. Families in the U.S. have been making determined efforts to lower their outstanding loans. The debt-to-disposable-income ratio in the U.S. has been on a downtrend for the past couple of years.

In Canada, the same ratio continues to climb. It has reached 151%, which is above the figure south of the border.

With very low interest rates, the Bank of Canada is worried that purchasers have been taking on risky mortgage commitments. Mortgages are a big part of household debt. People may be buying too much house. Or at least, that’s the way this is usually expressed.

While the foregoing are valid concerns, the bigger problem for Canadian homebuilders may be the product mix. Multi-unit starts have been much stronger than in the single-family market.

In January, singles were +1% (in units) and multis were +37%. The super-heated action has been mainly in Vancouver and Toronto. There’s little doubt that much of the demand is coming from investors in newly-wealthy regions of the world.

This creates a unique dilemma – trying to assess whether or not the foreign demand for properties in those two centres will hold up. If the world economy slows, as expected, the likelihood diminishes.

In contrast to Canada, U.S. home starts remain depressed. Interest rates are at record lows, but even highly-qualified potential buyers are having trouble winning mortgage approvals.

Once bitten by the credit crunch, the lending sector remains skittish.

At the same time, jobs are on the increase.

In fact, the improvement in the U.S. jobs market is probably more dramatic than most Americans realize.

It is true that total employment in the U.S. remains well below its peak level prior to the recession. In January 2008, U.S. employment reached an all-time high of 138.0 million. Over the next two years, it dropped by 8.8 million to strike bottom at 129.2 million in February 2010.

Since then, nearly another two years has passed and total American employment is 132.4 million. That’s an increase of 3.2 million versus the trough.

About one-third of the decline has been recovered. That may not sound like a lot, but consider the following.

The U.S. service sector accounts for 70% of all jobs. Total service sector jobs in the nation dropped 4.6 million from January 2008 to December 2009. They have since come back to the tune of 3.1 million jobs.

The recovery rate in services has been nearly 67%.

In a couple of categories, the current level of employment has actually risen above where it was before the recession.

The most amazing upsurge has occurred in accounting and bookkeeping services.  This is a category that lost jobs steadily over the three years 2008, 2009 and 2010.

In a relatively short period of time (i.e., one year), it has recovered fully. The slope of the curve showing job gains is extremely steep. The latest year-over-year change in employment is a remarkable +10.9%.

Computer system design services employment is +4.4% year over year and +10.2% versus its August 2009 low point.

And leisure and hospitality is a third category where employment has now returned to the same or higher level than its previous peak prior to the downturn.

Unfortunately, U.S. construction employment remains mired in the same deep trough it fell into at the beginning of 2010. It has remained flat for the past two years, although there are some tentative signs of improvement.

One encouraging note is that positions in architectural and engineering services are +2.5% year over year. This is a leading indicator for on-site work and indicates that more construction jobs are on the way.

Alex Carrick

Find Canadian construction-related economic articles in Canadian Construction Market News and in the Economic Outlook section of Daily Commercial News.


RSS Feed

» back to blog home

Member Comments

Post Your Own Comments 
» Not a member? Register now to become one. Otherwise, login to post your comments on this article.

Read Other Recent Alex Carrick Posts

05/14 - Economic Nuggets - May 15, 2012
05/11 - Canada Rode a Second Consecutive Month of Strong Job Gains in April
05/04 - U.S. Employment Rose by a Mediocre 115,000 in April
04/27 - U.S. GDP +2.2% in Q1 2012 and Alberta led Canadian Provinces in 2011
04/18 - U.S. Inflation Low in March; Canada’s Central Bank Looking to Raise Rates
04/12 - Canada’s Trade Surplus in February Declined but Business is Optimistic
04/03 - A Tale of Two Budgets
03/29 - A strong year for new construction investment intentions in 2012
03/21 - Leading Indicator Series Add to Good News about the U.S. and Canadian Economies
03/06 - Three key trends, more forays into high-tech and the importance for construction
02/29 - Two important sources of strength: share prices and non-residential construction
02/22 - Home resale market may be picking up in the U.S. while flattening in Canada
02/16 - Good news on U.S. housing and employment is positive for Canada as well
02/03 - Canada’s labour market flat in January but U.S. on a roll
01/23 - Canada’s leading indicator series continued to charge ahead in December
01/12 - 2012 holds promise but there’s no denying the uncertainty (part 2)
01/11 - 2012 holds promise but there’s no denying the uncertainty (part 1)
01/04 - How stock prices have performed depends on the timing of the data points
12/22 - Canada stands firmly in the middle of the road as it enters 2012
12/14 - Trade issues climb the agenda in both Canada and the U.S.

click here to update your log-in and member information

click here to maintain your company profile & view metrics