This is a post from Alex Carrick's blog that covers the Canadian construction industry.

Since 1985, Mr. Carrick has held the position of Canadian Chief Economist with Reed Construction Data's CanaData, the leading supplier of statistics and forecasting information for the Canadian construction industry.

Go to Alex Carrick's blog home

Construction Industry Forecasts

Notes from Alex Carrick - Jun 21, 2010

Alex Carrick
The good, the bad and the ugly about the HST

As of July 1 2010, the basket of goods and services covered under two provincial sales tax regimes will be stretched much wider. The cause will be a shift to harmonized sales taxes (HST) coordinated with the federal government.

The HST will be collected by Revenue Canada and the appropriate proportions remitted to the provinces of Ontario and British Columbia.

Federal goods and services tax coverage (GST) is broader in scope than present provincial sales taxes. Therefore, the new HST will be more wide-ranging in its application.

The federal goods and services tax rate is 5%. Existing provincial sales taxes (PSTs) will be added on top.

The new HST in Ontario will be 13%. In B.C., it will be 12%.

Ontario and B.C. account for slightly more than half of the nation’s gross domestic product (GDP).

On the same day, the existing HST in Nova Scotia will move up from 13% to 15%.

What I don’t like about the harmonized sales tax is also what I do like about it. It’s a tax grab.

Governments everywhere need more money. That’s federally, provincially and at the municipal level in Canada. It’s also true in Washington and in the states and cities south of the border and in almost every other jurisdiction around the world.

This is the fallout from massive government spending programs to stimulate economies out of recession.

In Europe, the push is on to wrestle government deficits and debt under control by raising VATs (value-added taxes, similar to the GST), cutting public sector staffing and wages, extending retirement dates further into the future and restructuring labor markets.

The U.S. is gently tackling the issue by letting tax breaks for wealthy income earners expire. But much more needs to be done. It is not clear that significant progress will be made any time soon, with mid-term elections coming this November.

A number of U.S. states (e.g., California) have been poking and prodding at the bankruptcy bear and Washington is running a trillion dollar deficit. Unpopular steps will eventually need to be taken.

Ontario is making the shift to the HST more palatable for voters by issuing “transition cheques.” This is providing extra consumer spending with one hand while taking it away with the other. Nonetheless, it is proving effective in keeping opposition relatively quiet.

Ontario has the timing right, with a relatively neutral impact in the short term while the economy is still recovering, and the more significant drag being delayed until more prosperous times have returned.

In B.C., where there will be no transition cheques and there is a history of political activism, the outcry has been much more vigorous. Petitions are being signed and demands for a referendum on the HST’s introduction have gained considerable support.

There is also the argument the governments and many manufacturers make that under the old system, producers were stuck paying provincial taxes in areas where foreign competitors received a bye. These added to Canadian producers costs and raised their prices.

Now, due to the pass-along component of the GST, manufacturers’ costs should come down. This will make them more competitive versus imports and will lower the general price level.

There will be lower prices as a result of the HST? Who among the general population isn’t skeptical? Time will tell.

What I don’t like about the HST is that it’s a tax grab. If it’s in any way visible or comes to the attention of the public sector, it will be taxed.

There are not just normal taxes anymore. There are surcharges on taxes. This applies with respect to health care in Ontario. It applies to drivers’ license plates in Toronto. In many jurisdictions, there are extra charges for garbage collection and recycling bins. The list is long and growing.

Government intrusion into all phases of everyday life has become extensive and expensive for all private citizens.

The phrase “tipping point” has entered the common vernacular. Such a moment seems close at hand.

Politicians might as well know this. There may be a backlash. That’s the ugly part.

Alex Carrick

Find Canadian construction-related economic articles in Canadian Construction Market News and in the Economic Outlook section of Daily Commercial News. Mr. Carrick also has a lifestyle blog that can be reached by clicking here.


RSS Feed

» back to blog home

Member Comments

Posted by marcus
Yet another severe tax in one of the most taxed jurisdictions in the world...all to justify overpopulation, supporting people whom cannot live within their means, & lower quality of life for all. Hooray for progress.
Post Your Own Comments 
» Not a member? Register now to become one. Otherwise, login to post your comments on this article.

Read Other Recent Alex Carrick Posts

10/12 - Latest Economic Nuggets: Mid-October 2012
10/04 - Auto Sales Set a Blistering Pace in the U.S. and Canada
09/18 - Canada’s Energy Future is Assured, Right? Think Again
09/14 - Latest Economic Nuggets: Mid-September 2012
09/06 - Auto Sector Labor Relations will Play a Role in Construction Outlook
08/30 - Raucous Behavior in the Party Room Next Door
08/13 - Latest Economic Nuggets: Mid-August 2012
07/31 - Canada’s GDP Advanced a Timid 0.1% in May but Support Will Come from Better U.S. Home Prices
07/19 - Finding the Pearls in the Latest U.S. and Canadian Economic News
07/13 - Latest Economic Nuggets: Mid-July 2012
07/04 - U.S. Auto Sales Continue Bullish While Canadian Incomes Languish
06/28 - Three Pivot Points for the World Economy - U.S. Housing, Europe’s Conundrum and Oil Prices
06/14 - Economic Nuggets – June 15, 2012
06/06 - Canada’s First Quarter GDP Growth Met Expectations, But What Comes Next?
05/30 - Ontario has a Backbone of Strength for the Decade Ahead
05/14 - Economic Nuggets - May 15, 2012
05/11 - Canada Rode a Second Consecutive Month of Strong Job Gains in April
05/04 - U.S. Employment Rose by a Mediocre 115,000 in April
04/27 - U.S. GDP +2.2% in Q1 2012 and Alberta led Canadian Provinces in 2011
04/18 - U.S. Inflation Low in March; Canada’s Central Bank Looking to Raise Rates

click here to update your log-in and member information

click here to maintain your company profile & view metrics