May
15
2008

Resort cities still the most active housing markets

Jim Haughey

Seed Newsvine
What do you think?
View comments (0 total comments)
Register or Login to post comments

The most intense housing development in the US continues to be in the rapidly growing resort and retirement centers along the Carolina coast, the hurricane rebuilding region on the Gulf Coast, the manufacturing and business centers in the North Carolina Piedmont area and Austin and Houston in Texas. As depressed as local housing markets are, relatively intense housing development still continues in the South Florida coastal cities but interior Orlando and mid-Atlantic coast Sebastian-Vero Beach are the only Florida cities among the twenty-five metro areas with the most intense housing development.

Residential construction activity was marginally higher during the winter quarter than the low point last December but activity continues to decline in the most distressed markets and home prices continue to decline in most markets. Adding to homebuilders’ problems, consumer confidence has fallen to a recession level in the low 60’s and mortgage rates remain near 6%.

Houston is the largest single family housing market. Atlanta, Dallas and Phoenix have fallen well behind. Houston largely escaped the rapid run up in home prices earlier in the decade because of its’ builder friendly zoning and permitting practices. Houston homeowners have relatively few problems now with adjustable mortgage rate resets and plunging home prices. New homes for New Orleans refugees and the booming energy industry are also contributing significantly to strong home demand.

Top Single Family Permit Metros   Top Multi Family Permit Metros
Metro SF Permits
Last 12 Months
  Metro MF Permits
Last 12 Months
Houston 37,401   New York 40,772
Atlanta 25,673   Houston 18,760
Dallas-Fort Worth 24,647   Los Angeles 15,427
Phoenix 19,881   Dallas-Ft Worth 14,981
Chicago 15,686   Chicago 12,837
Riverside 13,304   Seattle 12,013
Charlotte 12,881   Las Vegas 11,109
Washington 12,845   Atlanta 10,446
New York City 11,513   Austin 8,401
Raleigh 11,348   Washington 8,267
Austin 11,248   Phoenix 7,897
Seattle 10,626   Miami 7,220
Orlando 10,400   Orlando 6,927
Las Vegas 10,368   Denver 6,251
Nashville 9,350   San Francisco 5,696
Philadelphia 8,946   Charlotte 5,650
San Antonio 7,942   San Antonio 4,437
Los Angeles 7,621   Boston 4,219
Denver 7,228   Portland 3,730
St. Louis 7,225   Philadelphia 3,660
Tampa 7,201  
Source: Census Bureau

Houston has also moved to #2 on the list of top multi-family markets. Multi-family permits have nearly doubled since 2005 in contrast to 50-70% declines in 2005’s hottest condo and apartment markets. New York City is still the top market. Permits have declined very marginally in the last two years but deeper cutbacks are expected soon following layoffs in the city’s financial markets.

New Orleans is again the only large metro area with a growing housing market. This is due to hurricane rebuilding and a booming energy market. There is no signal yet that these two growing sources of new home demand will stop growing in 2008. But they are not enduring long tem sources of expanding new home demand. Each of the smaller cities on the list has a unique source of job and income growth. Four are being boosted by hurricane rebuilding and most of the rest are college town with more stable jobs or oil towns with rising energy industry employment.

Largest Decline in Permits from Early
2006 National Housing Boom Peak
(3 month total)
  Largest Increase in Permits from Early
2006 National Housing Boom Peak
(3 month total)
Metro # of Permits   Metro # of Permits
Atlanta -10952   New Orleans 949
Riverside -8525   Gulfport-Biloxi, MS 720
Phoenix -8516   Columbia, MO 677
Chicago -7630   Greenville, NC 652
Miami -6337   Pascagoula, MS 411
Las Vegas -5960   Lubbock, TX 388
Cape Coral -5928   Columbus, GA-AL 360
New York -5287   Mobile, AL 334
Tampa -5169   Beaumont-Port Arthur, TX 282
Dallas -4479   Columbus, IN 191
Los Angeles -4478   El Paso, TX 178
Washington -3831   Johnson City, TN 170
Lakeland FL -3653   Macon, GA 126
San Antonio -3427   Clarksville, TN-KY 120
Jacksonville -3226   Bismarck, ND 97
Orlando -3217   Florence-Muscle Shoals, AL 94
Houston -3032   Morgantown, WV 84
Bradenton-Sarasota-Venice -3024   Tulsa 70
Minneapolis -2445   Missoula, MT 62
Myrtle Beach -2426   Ithaca, NY 52
Source: Census Bureau

Atlanta leads the list of cities with the largest drop in housing permits from the peak in the housing boom two years ago. Excessive inventory is a bigger problem than declining home prices. Excepting Dallas and Houston, the other hard hit markets have experienced price declines that are causing a postponement in home purchases. Southwest Florida and Las Vegas/Phoenix will be the last markets to recover because the collapse of the local housing markets has led to significant local economic recessions.

For more information, please see US Metro Housing Markets – January 2008 – Cities 1-100.


Member Comments 

» View all comments (0 total comments)
Post Your Own Comments 
» Not a member? Register now to become one. Otherwise, login to post your comments on this article.